Skip to main content

Why Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel's Story Falls Flat and How It Could've Been Better [SPOILERS]


Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel!, 

released in 2014, is set chronologically between the games Borderlands and Borderlands 2. When it was released, it was under slight controversy because of the differences between it and it's predecessor, Borderlands 2.

Borderlands: TPS was produced by the Australian subdivision of 2K, the Borderlands series publisher. Since 2K is American, there is a large difference between the values of the studios. Most notably is the fact that the setting of Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel is more or less Australia in space.

What went wrong?

This wouldn't be that bad if not for 2K Australia's determination for making the game as Australian as possible.

But the game's blatant Australian-ism isn't what does it in, no. I believe the problem lies in the story and the lack of uniqueness and memorability. See, since BL:TPS is set between the first two games, it's seen as a side story, a spinoff of sorts, not a part of the real series. This, unfortunately means that it's generally less memorable in general. However, that isn't the fault of the writing.

The writing does come into play, however, when you look at the game in comparison to Borderlands 2. Borderlands 2 is chock full of unique dialogue, interesting characters, new areas, etc. It's cited as being the best in the series thus far, but that's just an opinion. Borderlands:TPS, since it is technically an aside to the original story, lacks much of the uniqueness that captivated players in Borderlands 1 and 2. The characters and their interest come into question as well. Unfortunately, some character simply fall flat in general. Many characters are seen as "annoying" or "boring" in the eyes of players for one reason or another.

So how could they have done better?

Well, that's hard to say. A fix to the lack of uniqueness and could very well be a more defined and streamlined user experience, but it could also be improved by putting more thought into the dialogue. Much of the dialogue in BL:TPS isn't bad, but compared to BL2 it could've had more work and time put into it.

The characters could very well have been improved by the same solution. By taking more time to define each character's traits, dialogue, motivation, etc. Take one of the game's bosses, The Bosun. The Bosun is an ex-computer programmer who is running the crashed spaceship in which he is fought, but past that he's... Not much. He's misogynistic and generally a mean and crude man, but doesn't have any other defining traits or motivations. By improving characters like this, it may help to improve the game's general sense of worldbuilding and thus help with its uniqueness.

My tip for today: even when in a crunch, take the time to think out ever move deliberately. You may get a pat on the back for a day of good work, but you'll be a legend for a lifetime of it.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How Half-Life Creates a Hidden Multiverse [SPOILERS]

If you played Half-Life and Half-Life 2 without fully grasping the entire plot, I don't blame you. There's a lot to take in. Not the least of which is the massive multiverse in which the games take place. It's very easy to miss, but in fact both games' main antagonists come from elsewhere in this multiverse. In the first Half-Life, the main antagonist, the Nihilanth, is actually running from the main antagonist of Half-Life 2 during the events of the game. The Nihilanth is the last of its kind, hunted to extinction by the Combine, the antagonists of Half-Life 2. The Combine are essentially inter-dimensional conquerors whom enslave entire species and drain entire planets of their resources. Half-Life starts the series as a simple alien-themed FPS, but with the introduction of Half-Life 2 the series quickly evolves into a massive story about the inhabitants of Earth fighting back against inter-dimensional forces. The plot in these games are fairly subtle, probabl...
Post a Comment
Read more

VGWriteReview: VA-11 HALL-A: Cyberpunk Bartender Action (Spoiler-Free)

VGWriteReview: VA-11 HALL-A: Cyberpunk Bartender Action I recently finished VA-11 HALL-A and I have a lot to say about it. As a perfect, comfy world filled with mystery and a sense that everything is a little familiar, VA-11 HALL-A's cyberpunk future gives me the sense that the game had a lot of love poured into it, and in this article, I intend to go over what exactly makes it so special to me. The Writing Let's start off strong: since VA-11 HALL-A is a technically a visual novel, the writing is very important. VA-11 HALL-A is written better than your average visual novel, and much MUCH better than your worst visual novel. With Fernando Damas (@IronicLark on Twitter) behind the wheel as the writer/programmer, the game benefits from a perspective set deep in real internet culture and a strong relationship with the game's aesthetics. Writing: 9/10 The Art VA-11 HALL-A is pixel art, technically. That aside, it has a lot of care and love put into each and every f...
Post a Comment
Read more

5 Ways to Improve Your Visual Novel

5 Ways to Improve Your Visual Novel Working on a visual novel, or "VN?" Well, you may not be considering how you can change your VN from a pile of messy writing to a masterpiece. There will be spoilers for numerous games in this article, but if you're looking for tips you can't help studying others. 1: Don't play the cliche, or at least play it well. This one might be obvious, but it's important to state anyway. Too often do I see visual novels which strive to be a "perfect trope" as I like to call it. These novels cherry-pick the exact hooks needed to make a product clamber to otakus like flies on, well... you get the point. Take the very popular series from recent years, the Sakura series. Seen as a staple of the genre in recent years, the Sakura series is essentially a toned-down eroge (or erotic game). With its flashy and explicit art and lack of substantial plot, the games attract a strange crowd and have thus gained a certain reputation....
Post a Comment
Read more